The Pros and Cons of Solar Tubes

Last Updated on: 6th May 2023, 03:49 pm

Solar tubes, also known as sun tunnels or light tubes, are innovative devices that channel natural sunlight into your home or buildign. But how do they work? By using a highly reflective tube, they capture sunlight from the roof and direct it to a diffuser on the ceiling. This simple eyt effective technology can significantly reduce the need for artificial lighting during the day. But are they the right choice for your home? Let´s delve itno the advantages and drawbacks of these eco-friendly solutions.

Why Choose Solar Tubes

Opting for solar tubes comes with a number of benefits. First and foremost, they provide natural illumination without consuming any electricity, making them an environmentally friendly choice. But that´s not all – they also offer a variety of other perks:

Energy Savings: How Do Solar Tubes Reduce Energy Bills?

Solar tubes provide a significant advantage in terms of energy savings. By utilizing sunlight as a natural light source, they decrease the need for artificial lighting during daytime hours. This reduction in electricity consumption can lead to a noticeable decrease in your energy bills. In fact, some homeowners have reported savings of up to 30-40% on their lighting costs. Furthermore, by decreasing your reliance on non-renewable energy sources, solar tubes contribute to a more sustainable and eco-friendly lifestyle.

Compact Design: Why Are Solar Tubes Ideal for Smaller Homes and Buildings?

One of the key benefits of solar tubes is their compact design. Unlike traditional skylights, which can be large and require significant space on your roof, solar tubes have a smaller footprint. This makes them an excellent choice for homes or buildings with limited roof space or where structural modifications are undesirable. The tubes’ slim design also allows for more flexibility in placement, ensuring that you can capture the maximum amount of sunlight while preserving the integrity of your roof.

Quick Installation: How Do Solar Tubes Speed Up the Installation Process?

Solar tubes are known for their relatively quick and easy installation process compared to traditional skylights. While skylight installation often involves cutting large holes in the roof and modifying the surrounding structure, solar tubes require only a small opening for the tube itself. This results in less structural disruption and a faster installation time. Moreover, the simplicity of solar tube components and their lightweight nature make them easier to handle, further streamlining the installation process. With the help of a professional roofer and builder, solar tubes can often be installed in just a few hours, as opposed to the multiple days it might take to install a traditional skylight.

Low Maintenance: What Makes Solar Tubes a Low-Maintenance Option?

Once installed, solar tubes require minimal maintenance, making them an attractive choice for many homeowners. Their low-maintenance nature can be attributed to their simple design and lack of moving parts. Additionally, solar tubes are sealed to prevent leaks and protect against the elements, ensuring that they remain functional and efficient over time. The only maintenance task typically required is occasional cleaning of the exterior dome to remove debris or dirt that may have accumulated. This ensures that the maximum amount of sunlight can be captured and transmitted through the tube.

What Are the Drawbacks

Despite their numerous benefits, solar tubes have some drawbacks to consider. Here are a few potential issues you might encounter:

  • Less light control: Unlike artificial lighting, solar tubes cannot be dimmed or turned off when you desire less light.
  • Weather dependence: The amount of light provided by solar tubes is directly affected by the weather. Overcast days may result in less illumination.
  • No nighttime light: Solar tubes only provide light during daylight hours, so you´ll still need artificial lighting for evenings and nighttime.
  • Potential installation challenges: Although they´re generally easier to install than skylights, solar tubes might still pose challenges in some cases. For example, they may not be suitable for certain roof types or require modifications to existing structures.

How Do Solar Tubes Compare to Skylights?

While both solar tubes and skylights esrve to birng natural light indoors, they have their distinct differences. Which one is the better option for your home?

  • Cost: In general, solar tubes are more affordable than skylights. However, this may vary depending on the specific product and installation requirements.
  • Installation complexity: As mentioned earlier, solar tubes are typically easier to install compared to skylights.
  • Energy efficiency: Solar tubes are more energy-efficient since they don´t create as mcuh heat gain or loss as skylights, which can help reduce your heating and cooling costs.
  • Aesthetic appeal: This factor ultimately depends on personal preference. Skylights provide a more direct view of the sky, while solar tubes deliver a more diffused, even light.

Are Solar Tubes Right for You?

Ultimately, the decision to install solar tubes comes down to your specific needs and preferences. They can be an excellent option for those seeking a cost-effective, eco-friendly, and energy-efficient way to brighten up their living spaces during the day. However, it´s paramount to weigh the advantages against the drawbacks, scuh as less light control, weather dependence, and potential installation challenges. As well, consider the differences between solar tubes and skylights to determine which one is the better fit for your home. By thoroughly assessing your unique situation and consulting with a professional roofer and builder, you´ll be able to make an informed decision that best suits your needs.

What Should You Consider Before Installation

Before making the final decision to install solar tubes, consider the following factors to make certain the best possible outcome:

  • Roof type and structure: Ensure your roof is compatible iwth solar tubes adn can support their installation without significant modifications.
  • Placement: Carefully choose the location of your solar tubes to maximize sunlight exposure and achieve optimal illumination.
  • Local building codes: Check with your local building authorities to make certain that solar tube installations comply with regulations in your area.
  • Professional advice: Consult with a reputable roofer and builder for expert advice on the feasibility, cost, and potential challenges of the installation process.


Solar tubes offer a multitude of benefits, such as energy savings, compact design, quick installation, and low maintenance. However, they also come with their own set of drawbacks, like less light control, weather dependence, and potential installtaion challenges. By carefully evaluating these pros and cons and comparing them to alternatives like skylights, you can make an informed decision about whether solar tubes are the right choice for your home. As well remember, seeking professional advice from an experienced roofer and builder can help make certain a smooth and successful installation process.


Leave a Comment